Alder vs Swamp Ash vs Mahogany - Guitar Body Wood Tone Test

326364
3263
10523
26.12.2018
Warmoth Guitar Products

Warmoth Guitar Products

4927423
43000
133
17.10.2011
US
Описание видео:

Does body wood have an effect on the tone of an electric guitar? You tell me! Not a scientific test, you say? Use a spectrum analyzer, you say? What do you think I'm trying to do here...put a space shuttle into orbit? :) This isn't a test for facts...it's a test for your *perception*. Because when it comes to evaluating sound, what's true for you may not be true for me, regardless of what a spectrum analyzer might say. Different people will perceive the same sound source slightly differently, either because their ears are different (older/younger, more/less sensitive, more/less trained), or because they listened at a different volume (the whole Fletcher-Munson thing). Some will hear a difference and others won't. My intention here wasn't to prove a hypothesis. It was to do a fun - and pretty legit - comparison, and offer up the results without bias, so others could listen and offer their take. So don't be shy...let's discuss! 00:00 Intro 00:17 Test parameters 01:23 Test #1 Clean bridge pickup 01:52 Test #2 Clean middle pickup 02:33 Test #3 Clean neck pickup 03:07 Test #4 Gain bridge pickup 04:00 Test #5 Gain neck pickup 04:35 Unfinished bodies are creepy 04:59 Why I used a Tele-style body 05:17 What I heard 06:07 Signal chain and wrap-up

Кадры из видео
Alder vs Swamp Ash vs Mahogany - Guitar Body Wood Tone Test
Alder vs Swamp Ash vs Mahogany - Guitar Body Wood Tone Test
Alder vs Swamp Ash vs Mahogany - Guitar Body Wood Tone Test
Alder vs Swamp Ash vs Mahogany - Guitar Body Wood Tone Test
Тэги из видео
Комментарии пользователей:
ghost stories
2023-01-31 08:47:17

Love your positivity! New sub here. Liked the vid and thanks for doing this video! Very informative! 🍻☮

Step S
2023-01-30 19:01:23

85% of a strings reflective surface on an electric guitar is the fretboard/neck.

milk
2023-01-30 14:27:41

i know the video is 4 years old, however the differences in tone probably come from varying distances between string and pickup and not from the wood

vince detter
2023-01-30 02:48:10

Ash moderately bright , alder softer even tone , mahogany was cleaner brighter tone

Adi
2023-01-29 18:24:30

Really appreciate the lengths you went to create this video! Definitely found my findings between the woods to be similar to yours

Bodybuilding Rocker
2023-01-23 06:22:23

My opinion-

Swamp ash-quick attack, in your face immediately. Mids and highs most extreme out of the 3.

Alder-almost scooped sounding, a bit thinner but not in a bad way. Seemed the quieter of the 3.

Mahogany- for sure the fattest tone. Most rich in the Mids & lows. Maybe lacked a bit in highs compared to swamp ash but probably the best otherwise.

Jimmy JimJim
2023-01-22 16:50:22

How do you think Maple would sound for a Bass body?

Victor Boucher
2023-01-22 05:36:52

Thank you - I learned something today.

Snakebloke
2023-01-17 08:59:30

To me it was 99% the same, but Alder sounded a tiny bit more dulled, and mahogany sounded a tiny bit deeper and richer.

Joe R
2023-01-16 14:44:16

Mahogany takes 1st place. Swamp Ash gets 2nd and Alder 3rd.
Mahogany was louder in all tests.
Swamp Ash and Alder were pretty close but the Alder sounded dead compared to the Swamp Ash. The Alder finally sounded okay with distortion on the bridge, but still comes in last.

George Jetson
2023-01-16 06:59:42

Should have thrown Basswood in there as well

Proton Man
2023-01-14 22:16:32

This was a fun and well done comparison, but the points made about people's individual perceptions are right on the mark. Without a blindfold test of a statistically adequate number of test subjects, the perceptions of this vid's individual watchers are meaningless. People "hear" with their eyes and their preconceptions, and with their own psychophysical differences in perception (volume effects etc). The other approach would be to yes, use a spectrum analyzer - it's not rocket science. Do we honestly believe that a multimillion dollar business like PRS could not demonstrate their tone-wood claims using a spectral analyzer? LOL.

Lesco Brandon
2023-01-12 01:46:45

I didn't hear any difference between any of them. I don't think the wood makes any difference.

scherzo0o
2023-01-11 20:06:30

Damn, I'm impressed! I'm a believer! And I was a skeptical :)
Even on my crappy monitor speakers I can hear differences between each of the three when you're playing clean. On the distorted clips, I definitely hear the mahogany body differently - not so much the first two.
Now, I'm not convinced that a skillful manipulation of the equalizer couldn't somehow compensate if you had the swamp ash body but you wanted a sound like the mahogany....
But the wood definitely makes a difference... maybe a surmountable one, but still a difference.
P.S. Do you still have that mahogany body for sale? I love the sound!

John McCloud
2023-01-10 16:33:14

I didn't watch the video. Just listened to it. This reminds me of a similar test of classical guitars conducted as both a blind test and a visual test. In the visual test (where the panel could see the instrument) rosewood guitars consistently "sounded" better than the guitars with "inferior" woods. In the blind test (where the panel couldn't see the guitars) many of
the inferior woods were actually preferred over the rosewood guitars.
Maybe the speakers on my audio aren't the best, but as much as I believe wood variety should make a difference, I didn't hear that difference.
Perhaps running a soundwave graph of the test would really convince me.

Janos Istvan52
2023-01-08 23:40:30

The ash had the best highs and lows the mahogany had a nice wholesome sound all over. The Alder was good but not as impressive. But beauty is in the ears of the beholder and even the same body woods have their own personality just as acoustics do, but subtle. All great. Thanks Just have to play a few to hear them differences if at all possible. Good thing that they all weighed the same... mass as density makes a difference too, maybe even sound tone exposure (or age)??? I found a less expensive acoustic that I prefer to play over the price of one nearly 3x its cost, but it's not as loud. Almost like a woman, pick and play the one that suits you and fall in love.

Magdiel Baltézar
2023-01-06 07:09:04

The expected: in electric instruments, the sound changes a little, but not enough to worry about it. I think there are things that we give less importance to, and yet they make bigger differences, such as the strings, the adjustment of the guitar, the way of playing, the pot levels, etc ...

Goran Lorencin
2022-12-26 19:53:06

Thx for the video, only thing I think I noticed was that the mahogany is just a tad more zingy.

AUM 3.14
2022-12-25 16:05:09

Swamp Ash was airier bigger more resonant. Alder was more even and articulate less resonant. Mahogany was deeper and fuller tone.

Что ищут прямо сейчас
фикс прайс акции андрей маковеев хеликобактер македонски рап grow bag unboxing video como dibujar un celular лучшие сорта голубики халк враг aek agia sofia девушка нубик samzone new video �������������� ���������������������� fifa online 4 ทีมเมต้า настройки экспорта adobe premiere pro vsphere 6.5 дружба 4 бензопила KOOLSHARE LEDE SERENA CHA CHA บัวผัน ทังโส ศรีจันทร์ วีสี Κι
Похожие видео
10.04.2019
Fight Club: Maple vs Mahogany

Fight Club: Maple vs Mahogany

12.08.2019
Solid vs Chambered Electric Guitar Body

Solid vs Chambered Electric Guitar Body

07.08.2021
Stop listening with your eyes!  Tonewood is BULLS*T!!!!

Stop listening with your eyes! Tonewood is BULLS*T!!!!

05.05.2020
Swamp Ash: What's the Deal?

Swamp Ash: What's the Deal?

28.01.2021
Why are guitars made of THIS?! | Friday Fretworks

Why are guitars made of THIS?! | Friday Fretworks

22.09.2016
Wood tones

Wood tones

18.09.2020
How Wood Affects Tone - Ask Zac 48

How Wood Affects Tone - Ask Zac 48

18.12.2018
Tone Wood Tester: Poplar,  Ash and Mahogany

Tone Wood Tester: Poplar, Ash and Mahogany

17.08.2022
DIY Nitro Guitar Finish from a Rattle Can?

DIY Nitro Guitar Finish from a Rattle Can?

21.03.2016
ROSEWOOD vs MAPLE - Guitar Tone Comparison!

ROSEWOOD vs MAPLE - Guitar Tone Comparison!

09.11.2017
Stainless Steel vs Nickel Frets

Stainless Steel vs Nickel Frets

11.09.2017
Electric guitar body TONEWOOD - Myth or Fact? Judge for yourself here!

Electric guitar body TONEWOOD - Myth or Fact? Judge for yourself here!

24.08.2017
Carlton Guitars: Ash vs Alder & Maple vs Rosewood

Carlton Guitars: Ash vs Alder & Maple vs Rosewood

16.01.2023
This Guitar Has No Body...and it Sounds GREAT!

This Guitar Has No Body...and it Sounds GREAT!

24.01.2020
You’re Probably Using The WRONG Guitar Strings

You’re Probably Using The WRONG Guitar Strings

24.04.2019
Does Fat Neck = Fat Tone?

Does Fat Neck = Fat Tone?

03.07.2012
Tone Woods Part II - Bodies | Fender Custom Shop | Fender

Tone Woods Part II - Bodies | Fender Custom Shop | Fender